The Supreme Court on 19 January 2021 granted Michael O'Callaghan leave to appeal in his damages claim against Ireland and the Attorney General. The case will decide whether the State's delay in hearing his criminal appeal breached his constitutional right to a fair trial with reasonable expedition.
Mr O'Callaghan was convicted of armed robbery in February 2011 and sentenced to ten years in prison. The Court of Criminal Appeal heard his appeal in April 2013. In July 2013 it allowed the appeal and quashed his conviction.
He says he spent two years and five months in prison between his conviction and that successful appeal. The Court of Criminal Appeal found that DNA evidence on a balaclava linked it to two other people as well as to him, so could not logically point to his guilt alone.
His damages claim has two parts. He argued that he was entitled to damages for judicial error, because the trial judge should have withdrawn the charge from the jury. He also claimed damages for a breach of his constitutional right to a speedy trial, focusing on the time between conviction and appeal while he was in custody.
Faherty J dismissed the claim in the High Court. The Court of Appeal, in a judgment by Ní Raifeartaigh J with Donnelly J and Power J agreeing, dismissed his appeal on 6 July 2020.
The court noted that Mr O'Callaghan had not applied for priority in the hearing of his appeal, nor sought bail while he waited. It also noted that a backlog in cases caused delays in getting hearing dates at that time.
The Supreme Court said it was not satisfied that any issue of general public importance arose on the judicial error claim. It said the law on damages for breach of the right to a speedy determination of criminal proceedings raises important issues.
Leave is granted on one ground only: whether the Court of Appeal erred in ruling that the delay in the appeal, so far as it was attributable to the State, was not unreasonable.
The determination was made by O'Donnell J, MacMenamin J and Charleton J.