The Supreme Court refused Dona Sfar leave to appeal on 16 April 2021 in her case over the seizure of her pigs and sheep on animal welfare grounds. Her case was against the Minister for Agriculture, the Attorney General and Ireland.
Officials had inspected her animals, served a Welfare Notice on 21 July 2014 and seized them on 8 August 2014 under the Animal Health and Welfare Act 2013. She challenged all of this by judicial review.
The High Court mostly rejected her claims. The Court of Appeal agreed on most points but sent one issue back for a rehearing in the High Court. That issue was whether parts of section 38 of the Act, which lets officers enter land, are compatible with the European Convention on Human Rights.
The Supreme Court said that issue appeared to be the key matter in her complaints. It saw no reason to disagree with the Court of Appeal that it should be debated further in the High Court. It therefore held that granting leave to appeal would not be appropriate.
The panel was Chief Justice Clarke, Justice McKechnie and Justice O'Malley.