The Supreme Court on 15 January 2021 refused Michael Forde SC and solicitor Neil McNelis leave to appeal a Court of Appeal ruling that stopped them joining an appeal in David Dully's case against Athlone Town Stadium Limited. They wanted to challenge remarks made about them by the trial judge.
They had acted as counsel and solicitor for the first-named defendant in the High Court but were replaced for the appeal. In his judgment of 6 December 2019 Humphreys J made remarks about each of them. They said these had an enduring impact on them.
On 17 July 2020, Costello J, sitting alone at a directions hearing, refused them permission to issue a motion to be joined as notice parties. The practical effect is that the remarks cannot be challenged in that appeal.
The Supreme Court said Costello J was entitled to manage her list as she did, so no matter of general public importance arose. It said the High Court made no orders or findings against them that could be reversed on appeal. The remarks were "comments and criticisms", not findings.
The judges said the pair were seeking to vindicate their professional reputations, not to argue that the orders under appeal were wrong. No order of the Court of Appeal could have met their complaint.
The court said it was unnecessary to decide whether time should be extended. Leave was refused.
The determination was made by Clarke CJ, O'Malley J and Baker J.