localnews.ie

Shay Sweeney and Limerick Private win Supreme Court appeal leave

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court granted the applicants permission to appeal over VHI’s effort to exclude their expert witness from proceedings about a proposed private hospital in Limerick.

Shay Sweeney and the Limerick Private Limited have been granted leave by the Supreme Court to appeal a decision excluding their expert witness from proceedings against the Voluntary Health Insurance Board Ireland (VHI). The determination was made on 8 April 2021.

The applicants sought to reinstate a High Court decision allowing Professor McDowell to act as their expert in a competition law case concerning VHI’s refusal to approve their proposed private hospital in Limerick. They claim that VHI’s refusal breached competition law; VHI denies the claims. The underlying proceedings began in 2015.

VHI had previously retained Professor McDowell as an expert in other proceedings involving private hospitals. It objected to his appointment by the applicants, arguing that his earlier work gave him access to confidential and privileged information. The High Court dismissed VHI’s application to exclude him and directed him to give an undertaking about his role and duties.

The Court of Appeal allowed VHI’s appeal and ordered that Professor McDowell be excluded. It found a real and obvious risk of confidential information being disclosed, while stressing that this did not impugn his integrity.

The Supreme Court’s determination grants leave to appeal; it does not decide the substantive appeal. The Court said the application raised specific questions about when a court should use its inherent jurisdiction to exclude an expert witness who had previously been engaged by another party. It considered clarification important because exclusion can have serious consequences for the party that retained the expert, and the issue could affect cases beyond competition law.

The Court also accepted that retaining an alternative expert could involve significant extra cost and that an appeal was necessary in the interests of justice while the applicable principles remained undefined. VHI had requested a priority hearing; the Court said the issue could be raised during case management.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal