Charles Kelly Limited’s dispute with Ulster Bank reached the Supreme Court on 16 March 2021, which refused former director William Kelly leave to appeal over joining the case.
Kelly sought to join the company’s negligence and breach of duty proceedings against the bank as a notice party. The High Court and Court of Appeal had both refused his application. He argued that the case could affect his interests and that he should be able to challenge evidence or findings concerning his conduct.
The Supreme Court said the constitutional criteria for granting leave had not been met. It said the Court of Appeal had not imposed a requirement that a person seeking to join proceedings must be a current director or shareholder. Rather, in light of the High Court orders, Kelly could not rely on those positions for his application.
The Court also said the bank was the party against which relief was sought and could decide how to defend the action. It refused permission for Kelly to file written submissions with his leave application. The ruling determined the application for leave; it did not decide the underlying dispute between Charles Kelly Limited and Ulster Bank.