The Supreme Court has granted Thomas Fox leave to appeal over the Government's refusal to set up an inquiry into the murder of his uncle, Seamus Ludlow. The determination was delivered on 11 March 2021. Mr Fox is the nephew of Mr Ludlow, a forestry worker who was murdered on 2 May 1976 in Dundalk, Co. Louth. Nobody has been charged in relation to the killing.
Mr Ludlow's family say he was an innocent victim of loyalist paramilitaries, or of people possibly linked to British State Security Services, in a case of mistaken identity. A Garda inquiry was stood down after weeks. The Barron Inquiry noted that some Garda information and files were missing or incomplete.
The Minister for Justice and Law Reform refused to establish an investigation or inquiry, although an Oireachtas Joint Committee had recommended one. Mr Fox sought judicial review, including a declaration and an order compelling an inquiry. The High Court refused judicial review, and the Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal. The Minister, the Attorney General and Ireland oppose his application.
Mr Fox now relies only on Article 2 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which protects the right to life. He is no longer pursuing his other arguments, on legitimate expectation, fairness and unreasonableness.
The Supreme Court found a general public interest in clarifying the State's duty under Article 2 to carry out an effective investigation into a death. It also said the case raises whether any such duty can apply to a death that happened before the Convention took effect in Ireland, where material facts emerged later. The Court said the issue goes beyond the facts of this case.
The Court added that it is in the interest of justice for it to consider the matter, as an appeal may bring finality to Mr Ludlow's family. The application was filed one day late because of a mistake about the rules on time, and the Court extended time without objection from the respondents. The panel was Chief Justice Clarke, Justice O'Malley and Justice Baker. The issues may be refined at an early case management hearing.