The Supreme Court on 15 January 2021 refused Brian McDonagh leave to appeal directly from the High Court against a €22.9m judgment obtained by Ulster Bank DAC. The bank brought the case with Paul McCann and Patrick Dillon, and the judgment was against Mr McDonagh and his co-defendants, Kenneth McDonagh and Maurice McDonagh.
The refusal means Mr McDonagh cannot go straight to the Supreme Court. If he wants to challenge the judgment, he must take the normal route of an appeal to the Court of Appeal.
Mr McDonagh applied on 14 August 2020 for a so-called leapfrog appeal. The High Court order was made on 23 July 2020. His only argument for going directly was that two appeals would cost more and that a second appeal was likely in any event.
The Supreme Court said a direct appeal needs exceptional circumstances. It said that an appeal that would "look the same" as one after the Court of Appeal can justify leapfrog leave only where there are extra factors, such as urgency. It was not satisfied that such circumstances had been shown.
The judges saw no reason why the Court of Appeal could not deal with all the issues Mr McDonagh wants to raise. That includes any suggestion that the High Court took a different approach to section 17(2) of the Civil Liability Act 1961 from a recent Supreme Court judgment.
Leave was refused. The determination was made by Clarke CJ, O'Malley J and Baker J.