Wojciech Orlowski, who is sought under a European Arrest Warrant, was granted leave by the Supreme Court on 9 March 2021 to appeal directly from the High Court against an order for his surrender. The court also placed a stay on that order until further order.
Binchy J in the High Court directed Mr Orlowski's surrender in a judgment of 4 February 2021. On 17 February 2021 he refused to certify that an appeal to the Court of Appeal was justified. Mr Orlowski argued that this refusal provided the basis for a direct appeal to the Supreme Court.
His application reached the Supreme Court office on the afternoon of Friday 5 March 2021. His solicitor said his surrender might take place on Monday 8 March.
Because of that possible urgency, the Chief State Solicitor's office was told a panel would meet at 10.30am on the Monday unless it was clear he would not be surrendered that day. The panel met as planned, but no formal confirmation came about whether he was liable to be surrendered. It considered the merits at 1.00pm.
The main issue Mr Orlowski wants to raise is that courts in Poland that would hear his case after surrender may not be constituted in accordance with law. He relies on a recent ruling of the Court of Justice of the European Union in A.B. and Others.
The Supreme Court said this is "at least a stateable proposition". It added that the state authorities had not given a clear commitment that Mr Orlowski would not be surrendered in the meantime, so it was in the interests of justice to grant leave.
Because of the urgency, no respondent's notice was filed, so the court did not know whether the Minister for Justice and Equality opposes leave. Either party may apply to the court on the stay or any other relevant matter.
The determination was made by Clarke CJ, O'Malley J and Baker J.