The Supreme Court on 22 February 2021 refused Brendan O'Sullivan leave to appeal in a loan case brought by Havbell DAC. He was challenging a Court of Appeal refusal to extend the time for an appeal.
Mr O'Sullivan took out a loan of €1,245,000 from Permanent TSB in August 2004. The loan was later sold to Havbell DAC along with many others.
On 7 March 2018 the High Court, O'Regan J, found that Havbell could recover €1,199,018.53 from him. The balance of the claim, €484,022.73, and all other issues were sent to a plenary hearing that has not yet taken place.
Mr O'Sullivan gave other High Court proceedings, to restrain a receiver from selling properties tied to the loan, as part of his reason for delay.
On 23 October 2020 the Court of Appeal refused to extend time. Whelan J said there was no evidence of a real mistake explaining the delay, and that his grounds appeared scattergun.
Mr O'Sullivan applied to the Supreme Court on 10 December 2020. He set out twelve grounds, but the court said none related to the question of extending time.
The Supreme Court said he had failed to give reasons for the two-year delay. It found none of his grounds reached the threshold of general public importance, and that leave was not needed in the interests of justice.
The determination was made by O'Donnell J, Charleton J and Woulfe J.