The Supreme Court on 19 February 2021 refused David Byrne leave to appeal against his convictions for four counts of false imprisonment and one count of robbery of €2.28m.
The convictions arose from a tiger kidnapping-style incident on 13 and 14 March 2005. A family was held while cash was taken from a Securicor van.
Mr Byrne was convicted at a fifth jury trial in Hilary term 2018. On 16 July 2018 he was sentenced to 13 years and six months on each count. The sentences run concurrently.
The Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal on 20 April 2020.
His argument concerned mobile phone records. The prosecution had obtained them under a 1983 Act procedure, although a newer 2005 Act procedure applied.
The trial judge held the data was requested without lawful authority. She found the breach of privacy was inadvertent and admitted the records. The Court of Appeal held that this decision was clearly correct.
Mr Byrne asked the Supreme Court to examine the limits of the "inadvertence" test. This included what senior gardaí should know about changes in the law.
The Supreme Court said the case turns on a very particular factual situation. It said refinements of the test will normally be dealt with case by case in the Court of Appeal.
The court was also not satisfied that the interests of justice required an appeal. Leave was refused.
The determination was made by O'Donnell J, Charleton J and Woulfe J.