The Supreme Court on 14 January 2021 refused John O'Connell leave to appeal in his case against the Building & Allied Trades Union and others. He wanted the court to review a Court of Appeal ruling on the recording of his High Court hearing.
Mr O'Connell has a separate appeal pending in the Court of Appeal. It is listed for hearing on 19 January 2021.
He has a transcript of the Digital Audio Recording (DAR) but wanted the audio itself.
On 6 March 2020 McGovern J in the Court of Appeal refused him an audio copy. He gave him liberty to take up the DAR transcript and said he could raise any problem with it again.
The litigation began in 2002. Mr O'Connell won a High Court claim that the union breached his constitutional right to earn a livelihood by refusing him membership. O'Connor J later awarded him €15,000 in general damages.
Mr O'Connell said the transcript he had paid for from a private stenographer was incomplete. The respondents denied that it was inaccurate.
The Supreme Court said it was unclear whether he had taken up the DAR transcript. If he had, he had not said what was wrong with it. If he had not, it was difficult to see how he could argue for the audio instead.
The constitutional criteria for leave were not met. The determination was made by Clarke CJ, O'Malley J and Baker J.