localnews.ie

Elizabeth McGrath District Court costs order case: DPP granted Supreme Court appeal

By Eimear Byrne

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court will decide whether the District Court can award costs against the DPP or gardaí in summary criminal cases. Issues may be refined at case management.

The Supreme Court on 9 February 2021 granted the Director of Public Prosecutions leave to appeal in a case against District Judge Elizabeth McGrath. The case is about whether the District Court can order the DPP, or a member of An Garda Síochána, to pay costs in criminal proceedings.

The dispute began with prosecutions against John Matthews and Gerard Gearty. The DPP later abandoned the prosecutions, and the District Court made a costs order.

The DPP sought judicial review of that order. It argued that the District Court has no power to award costs against it in summary criminal proceedings, relying on Order 36 Rule 1 of the District Court Rules 1997. Hanna J in the High Court quashed the costs order.

On 20 December 2019 the Court of Appeal overturned that decision in a judgment by Edwards J. Mr Matthews had argued that section 59 of the Dublin Police Act 1842 gave the District Court power to award costs. The Court of Appeal held that Order 36 Rule 1 went beyond the rule-makers' delegated power and that such a change needed primary legislation.

The DPP applied for leave on 16 October 2020. It said the issue affects the public interest in prosecuting offences, and that a long-standing immunity from costs orders had been upheld by the Supreme Court in an earlier case. It also said the ruling could affect costs orders in the Circuit Court.

Mr Matthews said the Court of Appeal dealt correctly with issues of general public importance. If leave was granted, he put forward a cross-appeal on an alternative basis for the costs order under Order 38 Rule 1(4).

The Supreme Court said it would be in the public interest to obtain clarity on the District Court's jurisdiction over costs in summary criminal proceedings.

The issues are not final. The court listed three provisional questions: whether Order 36 Rule 1 is beyond the rule-makers' powers, whether it alters the jurisdiction in section 59, and whether the District Court can award costs and on what criteria. They may be refined at case management.

The determination was made by O'Donnell J, Charleton J and Woulfe J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal