The Supreme Court on 9 February 2021 refused Lisa Hennessy leave to appeal directly from the High Court in a case brought by Pepper Finance Corporation (Ireland) DAC. Derek Hennessy, her co-defendant, did not apply.
On 21 November 2017 the Circuit Court made an order for possession of the home, with a six-month stay. The Master of the High Court later extended the time for Ms Hennessy to appeal that order.
Pepper Finance challenged the extension. A hearing set for 1 April 2019 did not go ahead because Ms Hennessy did not attend, on grounds of ill health, and it was adjourned to July 2019.
When the motion resumed she was again absent. On 15 July 2019 Meenan J reversed the Master's order and struck out her appeal. She told the Supreme Court the case wrongly proceeded without her.
She applied for leave on 15 August 2019. She also raised issues about mortgage clauses and EU consumer law.
The Supreme Court accepted that she had been unwell, but said the application was misconceived. Pepper Finance accepted that she could have appealed to the Court of Appeal, and no basis was given for a direct appeal.
It said the High Court judge acted within his discretion, having been told the medical evidence was largely the same as before an earlier adjournment. The wider issues had not been dealt with in the High Court.
The determination was made by O'Donnell J, MacMenamin J and Charleton J.