The Supreme Court refused Karl O'Doherty leave to appeal directly from the High Court on 22 December 2021, in a possession case brought by KBC Bank Ireland PLC. The High Court's dismissal of his appeal against the possession order on his home in County Dublin stands.
The Circuit Court (Judge Linnane) granted KBC possession on 20 June 2017, with a stay on execution for three months. Noonan J. dismissed his appeal in the High Court on 5 February 2019.
The bank's affidavit said €331,889.62 was owing, including arrears of €82,472.79. The loan was €280,600, advanced under a 2005 offer to Mr O'Doherty and Natalie Murphy.
His application was filed on 1 August 2019, after the deadline. The court refused to extend time, as he gave no reasonable explanation for the delay. He had also not filed the approved court judgments that the Supreme Court's practice direction required.
Mr O'Doherty raised three points about mortgage clauses, consumer rights under EU law and the balance between financial institutions and vulnerable consumers. The court found them vague and generic, and not connected to the facts of his case. It found no matter of general public importance.
He had a full Circuit Court hearing and a High Court appeal where he could introduce additional evidence. The court saw no issue of EU law to refer to the Court of Justice of the European Union.
Leave was refused. The judges were O'Donnell C.J., O'Malley J., Baker J. and Woulfe J.