localnews.ie

Thomas and Mary O'Callaghan granted Supreme Court appeal in AIB consumer loan case

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Limerick couple argued they were consumers entitled to protections under the Consumer Credit Act 1995, which the High Court and Court of Appeal rejected.

The Supreme Court granted Thomas and Mary O'Callaghan leave on 20 December 2021 to appeal from the Court of Appeal, in a case brought against them by Allied Irish Banks PLC. The couple live at Drumcollogher, County Limerick. He is a poultry farmer and she is a nurse.

The bank sued them by summary summons dated 10 May 2017 for sums owed on two loan accounts and an overdraft. These came under a 2009 loan sanction, which restructured a package first approved in 2005 to finance a farming and development project in Slovakia.

In the High Court, Donnelly J. gave judgment on 29 April 2019 for €466,757.63, plus interest and costs. She rejected the couple's argument that they were consumers, and held that the borrowing was an investment. The Court of Appeal, in a judgment by Haughton J., upheld that finding but substituted a figure of €465,875.91 to allow for surcharge interest.

The couple argued that they were consumers under the Consumer Credit Act 1995 and had not been given the protections in section 30. The Court of Appeal said that no higher authority than AIB v Higgins existed in this jurisdiction. It accepted that a different approach might be taken in other decisions, and said the correctness of Higgins would fall to be decided in an appropriate case, though not this one.

The Supreme Court found that a matter of general public importance arises on the correct meaning of "consumer" for the purposes of the relevant legislation. It said the question may arise in a large number of cases and that further clarity is in the public interest.

The couple's application was filed late, as the first applicant cited Covid issues. The bank did not oppose an extension of time, and the court granted it.

The court urged the couple to contact the Registrar by 14 January 2022 about a scheme offering voluntary legal representation. The grounds may be refined in case management. The judges were O'Donnell C.J., Charleton J. and Woulfe J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal