localnews.ie

Christopher McDonald granted Supreme Court appeal over forensic samples in murder case

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The appeal concerns how far a suspect in custody can seek legal advice before agreeing to samples that the gardaí could otherwise take compulsorily.

The Supreme Court granted Christopher McDonald leave to appeal from the Court of Appeal on 10 December 2021. He was convicted in the Central Criminal Court of murdering Keith Walker at Blanchardstown Racing Pigeon Club, Clonsilla, on 12 June 2015, and was sentenced to life imprisonment.

The Court of Appeal, with Birmingham P. giving the decision and Edwards J. and Murray J. agreeing, dismissed his appeal. The prosecution case relied partly on DNA and firearms residue found on a wig and a glove recovered from a laneway in Blanchardstown on 16 June 2015.

Mr McDonald was arrested on 13 June 2015 and asked for a solicitor. Gardaí took swab samples from him between his brief telephone call with the solicitor and the solicitor's arrival at the station.

At trial, the defence argued that the samples were not shown to have been lawfully taken. If they were taken under the Criminal Justice (Forensic Evidence) Act 1990, the procedures had not been followed. If they were taken under a common law power, which required his consent, his constitutional right of access to a lawyer had been breached. The trial judge ruled that they were taken voluntarily under the common law power, and admitted the evidence.

The Court of Appeal considered the Supreme Court's decision in DPP v Gormley and White. It held that where a statutory power to take the samples compulsorily was available, the suspect had no genuine legal choice, so fair process did not require gardaí to wait for the solicitor.

The Supreme Court found that the case involves a matter of general public importance. This is the extent of the entitlement of a person in custody to access legal advice in respect of non-mandatory forensic sampling. It noted that the issue may arise in other criminal trials, and that it would be in the public interest to obtain further clarity.

The judges were MacMenamin J., Baker J. and Woulfe J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal