The Supreme Court refused Eamonn J O'Neill leave to appeal directly from the High Court on 2 December 2021, in his case against Ireland, the Attorney General, the Garda Commissioner and the Director of Public Prosecutions.
He wanted to appeal an order of Murphy J. made on 18 February 2019. She dismissed his motion for judgment in default of defence, together with a wide range of other orders pleaded in his statement of claim.
These included overturning previous convictions, an investigation into allegations of corruption he had made against members of the judiciary and the legal profession, an apology from Ireland, and a finding that Ireland was in contempt of court.
Murphy J. held that he was not entitled to default judgment, as a defence had been filed. She said the other orders could not be made on a motion, because they were yet to be decided at plenary hearing.
The Supreme Court said the order was the standard one made on a routine motion. It said no legal principle of general public importance was raised. It accepted that orders of that kind could be made only after a plenary hearing and evidence.
His application was over two years out of time. Because leave was refused on the merits, the court did not consider his request for an extension of time.
The judges were O'Donnell C.J., Charleton J. and Baker J.