The Supreme Court on 8 February 2021 refused Michael Egan and Eileen Egan leave to appeal directly from the High Court in a possession case brought by Pepper Finance Corporation (Ireland) DAC. The application concerned an interlocutory order made by Barrett J on 7 October 2019.
That order let Pepper Finance use affidavits of Caroline Loftus without producing her for cross-examination. It also refused the Egans' request to cross-examine her in their appeal from a Circuit Court order granting possession of the premises.
The couple claimed the High Court did not apply fair procedures. The Supreme Court said they gave no legal basis for that allegation.
The court said it rarely grants leave on interlocutory decisions, and the area of law was already governed by established case law.
The Egans had not filed a replying affidavit in the Circuit Court proceedings, so they had raised no issue of fact needing cross-examination. The court found no issue of general public importance and said the interests of justice did not require leave.
The application also failed under Practice Direction 19. A letter from the Registrar on 7 February 2020 told the couple what documents they had to file within seven weeks of the order being perfected.
They were warned that the application might be dismissed. The court said they failed to comply despite repeated notifications, which alone would warrant dismissal.
The determination was made by Clarke CJ, MacMenamin J and Baker J.