localnews.ie

Gemma O'Doherty and John Waters granted limited Supreme Court appeal on Covid-19 laws

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

Leave covers one question: whether leave for judicial review should have been granted without expert evidence on whether the Covid-19 restrictions were proportionate.

The Supreme Court granted Gemma O'Doherty and John Waters leave on 23 November 2021 to appeal from the Court of Appeal, but only on one issue, in their challenge to Covid-19 legislation and regulations. They had sought to bring a judicial review challenging the constitutionality of the Health (Preservation and Protection and other Emergency Measures in the Public Interest) Act 2020, the Emergency Measures in the Public Interest (Covid-19) Act 2020 and the Health Act 1947 (Section 31A – Temporary Restrictions) (Covid-19) Regulations 2020.

Meenan J. refused them leave to bring the judicial review in the High Court. The Court of Appeal then dismissed their appeal, with Birmingham P. holding that they "singularly failed to meet the threshold of establishing an arguable case".

The Supreme Court accepted that the Measures interfere significantly with constitutional rights, including family life, public worship, free movement and travel, freedom of assembly and the inviolability of the dwelling. It said the questions on their proportionality are "capable of having far reaching effect".

It also set out difficulties with the case. The applicants did not file further affidavits beyond those in their statement of grounds, and adduced no expert scientific, epidemiological or medical evidence. The court said they had not shown how they were personally affected.

Even so, the court found that the appeal raises questions of general public importance on the burden of proof when leave is sought to challenge the proportionality of the Measures. These concern the rights to liberty, free movement and travel, the inviolability of the dwelling and freedom of association. It said the issues may arise in other cases and that clarity would be in the public interest.

The court refused leave on the applicants' other grounds. These included claims about amendments to the Residential Tenancies Act 2004 and the Mental Health Act 2001, their right to livelihood, alleged bias and an alleged failure to hear the case in public.

The appeal will ask whether leave for judicial review should have been granted where no expert evidence was filed on proportionality, and whether the evidential burden then shifts to the respondents.

The court invited the applicants, who are unrepresented, to contact the Registrar within seven days about a scheme offering voluntary legal representation. It also reminded the parties that proceedings must be conducted with restraint, in language and behaviour. A priority hearing was not ordered. The judges were O'Donnell C.J., Baker J. and Hogan J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal