The Supreme Court refused Frank Brassil leave to appeal on 22 November 2021, over his convictions for dangerous driving and failing to provide a sample. He was arrested on suspicion of driving under the influence of alcohol.
At the garda station there was no key to access the breath-testing device, so a doctor was called at 5:35am. The doctor arrived at 6:30am, and Mr Brassil refused to give a blood or urine sample.
The District Court convicted him, fined him and disqualified him from driving for six years. The Circuit Court upheld the convictions, and the High Court and the Court of Appeal refused judicial review.
Mr Brassil argued that gardaí had given no explanation for the delay in getting a doctor. The Court of Appeal held that no explanation was required where a delay was found not to be unreasonable.
He asked the Supreme Court to set guidelines for detaining a person while waiting for a doctor. The court said this had not been raised in the lower courts, so it would be "operating in a vacuum".
It added that what is a reasonable wait depends on the facts of each case. It found no point of general public importance in his complaint about a missing transcript, or in the four years he said his Circuit Court appeal took. The judges were Dunne J., O'Malley J. and Hogan J.