localnews.ie

Joseph Behan granted Supreme Court appeal over search warrant in attempted robbery case

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The appeal concerns whether the garda officer who issued the warrant was independent of the investigation, as the Criminal Justice (Search Warrants) Act 2012 requires.

The Supreme Court granted Joseph Behan leave to appeal from the Court of Appeal on 15 November 2021, limited to the validity of a search warrant used in the case against him. He was convicted of a number of offences arising out of an attempted robbery at a premises in a shopping centre.

A firearm was discharged during the incident, and two staff members were injured, one of them with a life-threatening injury. Mr Behan's main complaint is that the search warrant, on foot of which incriminating evidence was found, was not validly issued.

The Criminal Justice (Search Warrants) Act 2012 allows a garda officer of at least the rank of superintendent to issue a warrant in urgent circumstances, where applying to a District Court judge is not practical. The officer must be independent of the investigation, meaning not in charge of it or involved in it.

The warrant was issued by Divisional Detective Superintendent Scott, after Superintendent Donnelly, who led the investigation, contacted him. The defence argued at trial that a divisional detective superintendent would normally be expected to be involved in an investigation like this.

The Court of Appeal said that an officer approached in these circumstances should be one who would not be expected to have any involvement. It found, however, that Superintendent Scott knew nothing of the incident when contacted and acted on his own view of CCTV footage. It held that he was sufficiently independent.

The Supreme Court was satisfied that Mr Behan had raised a matter of general public importance on the interpretation and application of the 2012 Act. It refused leave on a second complaint, that the trial judge prevented proper cross-examination, because the transcript did not bear it out and it had not been raised in the Court of Appeal.

The issues will be refined in case management. These include whether he alleges a breach of constitutional rights or of the statute, and whether such a breach would warrant excluding the evidence found. The judges were Dunne J., O'Malley J. and Hogan J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal