The Supreme Court refused Stephen Murphy leave to appeal in his case against the Garda Síochána Ombudsman Commission (GSOC) on 10 November 2021. The court said: "No matter of general public importance arises from this application."
The case began in 2017, when a JCB driving on a public road knocked down the telephone line to Mr Murphy's home in West Cork. He complained to Bantry Garda Station, then to GSOC, alleging that Garda Whitty had neglected his duty to investigate.
A superintendent investigated and found no breach of discipline, as Mr Murphy was told on 25 February 2019. GSOC reviewed the matter and told him on 18 July 2019 that it was concluded.
Mr Murphy, who represented himself, sought judicial review. The High Court refused leave on the basis that his challenge was out of time. The Court of Appeal, in a judgment by Collins J., considered the challenge was not out of time but found no arguable grounds.
He asked the Supreme Court to hear a further appeal, arguing he was denied fair procedures, including a right to cross-examine those interviewed. The court said there was no basis for concluding he was entitled to that. It added that there is no duty to give reasons for all administrative decisions.
He also alleged bias on the part of GSOC and of the Court of Appeal judge. The court said there was no basis in evidence for that allegation. The judges were O'Donnell C.J., MacMenamin J. and Dunne J.