localnews.ie

Saqib Ahmed granted Supreme Court appeal over no right to appeal Medical Council sanction

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

Leave covers a constitutional and human rights challenge to the Medical Practitioners Act 2007, but not his challenge to the finding of poor professional performance.

The Supreme Court granted Saqib Ahmed leave on 3 November 2021 to appeal from the Court of Appeal on specified grounds, in his case against the Fitness to Practice Committee of the Medical Council and the Medical Council.

Mr Ahmed is a registered medical practitioner who faced nine allegations before the Committee. It found one sub-allegation established, that he was guilty of poor professional performance in his treatment of a patient in 2012. The Medical Council imposed the sanction of "advice" and attached no conditions to his registration.

Under sections 71(a) and 75 of the Medical Practitioners Act 2007, no appeal lies where only advice has been imposed. The law has since changed, but the court noted that the change has no retrospective effect and so does not help him.

He brought a judicial review challenging the advice sanction as unreasonable or irrational. The High Court and the Court of Appeal both held that the Committee's finding had an evidential foundation, so its conclusion could not be called irrational. The Court of Appeal's judgment, delivered on 28 July 2021, was given by Donnelly J., with Faherty and Ní Raifeartaigh JJ. agreeing.

The Supreme Court refused leave on that challenge, because no discernible error of law had plausibly been identified. It also refused leave on a ground based on the equality provisions of Article 40.1. The Court of Appeal had found he never particularised such a claim in his judicial review.

Leave was granted on a separate constitutional issue. Mr Ahmed contends that the 2007 Act is unconstitutional because it gives no right of appeal in a case like his, even though the sanction affects his reputation and livelihood. He also seeks a declaration of incompatibility with the European Convention on Human Rights. The question is whether judicial review is an adequate remedy.

The court said the issue is in some respects novel and important, and has yet to be determined by it. It found that the constitutional threshold had been reached. The grounds may be refined at a case management hearing. The judges were Dunne J, O'Malley J. and Hogan J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal