The Supreme Court refused Emmett Corcoran and Oncor Ventures Limited, trading as "The Democrat", leave to appeal directly from the High Court on 22 October 2021. The applicants had challenged the search and seizure of Mr Corcoran's private residence and business premises, and the examination of his mobile phone.
Simons J. had dismissed that challenge on 4 January 2021. He allowed gardaí to examine certain content captured on the phone between 11 and 17 December 2018, but limited the information so that his sources could not be identified.
The applicants asked the Supreme Court to decide whether a procedure must be prescribed by law for a court to determine, before issuing a search warrant, whether a public interest overrides the protection of journalistic sources. They argued that this was a matter of general public importance. They pointed to a criminal trial listed for 11 January 2022 and to the Court of Appeal hearing fixed for 22 and 23 November 2021.
The Supreme Court said matters of general public importance might arise at the level of principle. It said a direct appeal was not justified. A hearing in the Supreme Court was unlikely before the Court of Appeal began its scheduled hearing, and the Court of Appeal might refine the principles.
The Garda Commissioner and the Director of Public Prosecutions opposed leave. As leave was refused, the court did not need to consider the application for an extension of time. The judges were MacMenamin J., Charleton J. and Baker J.