The Supreme Court granted Stephen Brady leave to appeal from the Court of Appeal on 13 October 2021, on one ground only.
Mr Brady was convicted in Monaghan District Court of being in possession of an unregistered vehicle on 25 November 2011. The District Judge imposed a fine of €5,000, or three months in prison in default of payment.
He appealed to the Circuit Court, which upheld the conviction but reduced the fine to €3,000. He later brought a judicial review. He argued that the vehicle was registered to his wife in Northern Ireland and was on temporary loan to him.
He said the Finance Act 1992 sections he was convicted under restricted the free movement of capital, which article 63 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union prohibits.
On 18 January 2021, the Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal. It held the evidence was insufficient to show that article 63 applied. It also found the judicial review wrongly constituted, because it did not name the Circuit Court for the County of Monaghan as a respondent.
Mr Brady then applied to the Supreme Court, which found that how proceedings to quash a District or Circuit Court decision should be framed under Order 84, rule 22(2A) has not been decided by the superior courts. It said this was of systemic importance and warranted leave.
It refused leave on the article 63 grounds. The court said the evidential basis had not been established.
It also ruled that a priority hearing was not necessary and expected the appeal to be heard in the normal course. The judges were MacMenamin J., Charleton J. and Baker J.