localnews.ie

Atlas Baltic OÜ denied Supreme Court appeal over ship costs

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court refused leave to appeal over pilotage and agency fees paid for the M/V Lady Magda.

Atlas Baltic OÜ was refused leave to appeal by the Supreme Court on 23 September 2021 over recovery of ship disbursements paid for the M/V Lady Magda.

The company sought to recoup costs, mostly pilotage and agency fees, from the ship’s owners after paying them on the vessel’s behalf. It argued that the owners had benefited from the services and should be liable for the costs despite the ship being under a time charter.

The Court of Appeal had upheld the High Court’s decision that Atlas Baltic was not entitled to recover the disbursements from the owners. The Supreme Court did not decide an appeal on its merits: it refused leave, finding that the application did not meet the constitutional threshold for an appeal.

The determination records that the High Court found the agents knew the charterers were not the owners, and that the evidence did not show the owners had ratified the charterers’ actions. The Court of Appeal held that those findings were supported by the evidence. The Supreme Court concluded that the case raised no issue of general public importance.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal