localnews.ie

Maurice Power fixed-term contract case: HSE granted Supreme Court appeal

By Orla Quinn

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Health Service Executive is challenging a High Court ruling that sent Maurice Power's fixed-term work claim back to the Labour Court.

The Supreme Court has agreed to hear an appeal by the Health Service Executive in its fixed-term work case against Maurice Power, in a decision delivered on 24 September 2021. The court said the issues are "likely to impact on a broad range of persons employed in the State".

The HSE applied for leave to appeal directly from the High Court, and the court granted it.

The case centres on whether an employee with undisputed permanent status, who fills a more senior role on successive fixed-term contracts for more than four years, can be treated as a "fixed-term employee" under the 2003 Act. If so, the employee may argue for a contract of indefinite duration under section 9, absent objective grounds for the fixed-term contracts.

Mr Justice Simons ruled on the matter in the High Court on 23 July 2021. He set aside a Labour Court determination of 5 August 2020, saying it had misconstrued the statutory definition of "fixed-term employee". He sent the matter back to the Labour Court for reconsideration.

The HSE argued that the case has potentially significant financial and human resource consequences for many other HSE employees. It also said the case raises the meaning of Clause 5 of a Council Directive on fixed-term work, which the CJEU has not determined.

Mr Power opposed leave. He said the claimed impact on other cases was an abstract assertion.

The Supreme Court said that the lack of an appeal to the Court of Appeal was not in itself a reason for leave. It said, though, that it was in the public interest to clarify the statutory provisions.

The issues may be refined at case management. The court said a formal order for a priority hearing was not needed, as it expected the case to be heard in the normal course without significant delay. The judges were Clarke C.J., O'Malley J. and Baker J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal