localnews.ie

Stefan Schaufler refused Supreme Court sentence appeal

By Saoirse Doyle

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court said the 15-year sentence, with six years suspended, raised no issue of general public importance. The Court of Appeal had upheld it.

The Supreme Court on 4 February 2021 refused Stefan Schaufler leave to appeal his sentence for causing serious harm, false imprisonment, robbery and unauthorised taking of a motor vehicle.

He pleaded guilty. The offences took place on 20 and 21 June 2018.

Judge Comerford set a headline sentence of 16 years. He sentenced Schaufler to 15 years, with six suspended, on the false imprisonment and serious harm counts.

He imposed seven years for robbery and two and a half years for the vehicle count. All sentences run concurrently.

The Court of Appeal upheld the sentences. It said it might have structured them differently but they were within the available range.

Schaufler argued the 16-year headline sentence exceeded the top of the then-applicable guideline range for serious harm. That range was seven and a half to twelve and a half years.

He also asked whether mitigation could be applied by suspending part of a sentence.

The Supreme Court said no issue of general public importance arose. The Court of Appeal was the appropriate forum, and the guidelines have since been revised.

It said the point did not truly arise. The guideline covered a single serious harm offence, but this case involved several serious offences.

Sentencing him as if he had committed only the serious harm offence would have been an error, it said.

The court extended time for the application but refused leave.

The determination was made by O'Donnell J, Charleton J and Woulfe J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal