localnews.ie

Supreme Court to hear An Taisce appeal over evidence in habitats planning challenge

By Rory Hanlon

Historic decision · Decision date:

The appeal goes straight from the High Court and concerns how evidence is dealt with in challenges to development consents near protected sites.

The Supreme Court granted An Taisce – The National Trust of Ireland leave to appeal directly from the High Court on 23 September 2021. The case concerns what evidence is needed when a development consent may affect sites protected under the Habitats Directive.

The High Court gave its judgment on 20 April 2021, in An Taisce's judicial review against An Bord Pleanála. Its order followed on 19 July 2021, and An Taisce applied to the Supreme Court on 5 August 2021, within time.

The other respondents were the Minister for Communications, Climate Action and the Environment, Ireland and the Attorney General. Kilkenny Cheese Limited, formerly JHOK Limited, was the notice party.

Under existing law, a consent for a development that may affect such a site can ordinarily be given only after an assessment finds no reasonable scientific doubt that the site's integrity will be preserved.

An Taisce said the trial judge had decided that a party challenging such a consent must put forward scientific evidence against the assessment. The Board said An Taisce had mischaracterised the judgment. It said the test only required an applicant to point to some aspect of the evidence that raised doubt, and that An Taisce had not done so.

The Supreme Court said there may be a legitimate debate over the test the trial judge applied. It did not think it appropriate at this stage to resolve that dispute.

It found that clarifying the proper approach to evidence and argument on scientific matters in judicial reviews of this type is a matter of general public importance. On that basis, it granted leave. The judges were Clarke C.J., O'Malley J. and Baker J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal