The Supreme Court refused Charlotte Puong leave to appeal on 15 September 2021. Charlotte is a minor and her mother, Phei Wooi Chew, brought the case with her.
They challenged the cancellation of Charlotte's Irish passport by the Department of Foreign Affairs. She was born in the State in 2018. The passport was cancelled after the Minister for Justice decided that her mother's residence had wrongly counted as qualifying.
The High Court granted certiorari, which quashes a decision. The Court of Appeal upheld it as to the citizenship decision but refused relief against the Minister for Foreign Affairs.
The Minister for Justice has since accepted that her mother had enough qualifying residence when she was born. Charlotte is entitled to be treated as an Irish citizen by birth.
She has been invited to make a fresh passport application. The Supreme Court held that the application was moot. It said it cannot direct that a passport be granted.
It said her position is now the same as if her mother's argument had been accepted before the case began. The panel was Chief Justice Clarke, Justice O'Malley and Justice Baker.