The Supreme Court refused barrister Eugenie Houston leave to appeal on 14 September 2021. The Court said her broad claims about judicial conduct did not arise from the Court of Appeal's judgment. Ms Houston wanted to appeal over five consolidated actions against members of the Bar Council, its Professional Practice Committee, the Barristers Professional Conduct Tribunal and the Appeals Board. The High Court dismissed her competition law, defamation and assault claims at the end of her case. The Court of Appeal upheld that.
She argued that the trial judge was biased and that she was denied fair procedures. The Court of Appeal rejected both complaints. It said:
"We are satisfied that the outcome was determined by the nature of the proceedings and their inherent weakness, rather than by reference to the procedures followed."
The Supreme Court said Ms Houston had not identified any specific Article of the Constitution, the EU Charter or the European Convention that she said was engaged. It said:
"It is not sufficient to make generalised assertions or complaints without in some way demonstrating how such matters could be said to have impacted on her proceedings."
She had said the courts deemed her "not a human being". The Supreme Court said no such finding was made. It found nothing in her application that met the constitutional threshold. The panel was Justice Dunne, Justice O'Malley and Justice Baker.