localnews.ie

Bernard and Helen McDonagh granted Supreme Court appeal in Clare County Council case

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Court said issues of general public importance arise on whether a housing authority and the courts must weigh proportionality before ordering a family to leave council land.

Bernard McDonagh and Helen McDonagh were granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court on 14 September 2021, in their case with Clare County Council. They are appealing a Court of Appeal decision that upheld injunctions ordering them to remove themselves from lands owned by the council.

The couple lived for several years as council tenants in Ashline, a small Traveller-specific housing development, where each of the houses was later destroyed by fire. They then lived in private housing but had to leave rented accommodation when the landlord required possession. The council says they refused reasonable offers and make unreasonable demands for Traveller-specific accommodation. The McDonaghs say the council has a policy of placing Travellers in standard housing without regard to the community's needs.

They moved onto the Ashline site, and the council obtained orders against them that they did not appeal. They moved to nearby land and left after consenting to a High Court order. They then moved to the site in the present case. The council relies on its ownership of the land, trespass and unauthorised development under the Planning and Development Act 2000.

The Court of Appeal held that the council had acted reasonably and proportionately and that the couple had established no stateable defence. It also held that the site was not their home within the meaning of the European Convention on Human Rights.

The Supreme Court extended time for the application, which was late. It noted that the couple had no legal help and that a friend, who is not professionally qualified, had drafted it. It found issues of general public importance, mainly on proportionality. These include whether a housing authority must consider the impact of removal and the family's prospects of lawful accommodation elsewhere.

The Court said the issues are too complex for the couple to argue themselves. It strongly urged them to contact the registrar about a scheme providing a solicitor and counsel. Redrafted grounds and submissions are due within four weeks, with the council to reply within three weeks after that. The panel was Justice Dunne, Justice O'Malley and Justice Baker.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal