localnews.ie

Ciarán Maguire refused Supreme Court appeal against surrender to Northern Ireland

By Niamh Kearney

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court said a reply from the Northern Ireland judge made clear no inference would be drawn from his silence in a Garda interview.

The Supreme Court on 4 February 2021 refused Ciarán Maguire leave to appeal against a decision that he can be surrendered to Northern Ireland under a European Arrest Warrant. The refusal leaves the Court of Appeal's decision in place.

Mr Maguire argued that surrender would breach his constitutional right to silence. Northern Ireland law allows inferences to be drawn when an accused stays silent in police questioning or at trial. He had been questioned by gardaí in Ireland, without a caution, about a different offence.

Binchy J in the High Court rejected his case and directed his surrender. He certified that the case involved a point of law of exceptional public importance. The Court of Appeal, in a judgment by Edwards J, dismissed his appeal.

The Supreme Court said the certificate does not decide whether leave should be granted, but it must be given due regard. It said the interests of justice test was not met, because his case had been decided twice.

Binchy J had asked the Northern Ireland court for further information. Judge Bagnall replied that the inference provisions apply to an interview under caution, so an interview without caution by another state's police could not lead to an inference.

The Supreme Court said it would take very cogent evidence to go behind such a statement. It found the potential issue could not arise on the facts, and that the constitutional threshold was not met.

The determination was made by Clarke CJ, O'Malley J and Baker J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal