localnews.ie

Kevin Molloy granted Supreme Court appeal over 30-month harassment sentence

By Gráinne Nolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court will examine whether a sentencing court can attach conditions to a suspended sentence that run beyond the suspended period.

The Supreme Court on 8 January 2021 granted Kevin Molloy leave to appeal against a sentence for two counts of harassment. The case concerns a debt collection business run by Mr Molloy.

Mr Molloy pleaded guilty in the Circuit Criminal Court in Mullingar to two counts of harassment under section 10 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act 1997. A co-accused pleaded guilty to two counts under section 11 of the same Act.

The sentence was 30 months from 30 September 2020. The final 12 months were suspended. The conditions were that he keep the peace and not engage in any debt collection for 7 years.

The Court of Appeal dealt with the case on 25 September 2020. Mr Molloy applied to the Supreme Court on 22 October 2020.

He argues that the sentence is contrary to law and attacks his right to follow his chosen career. He says a condition of suspension may last only as long as the suspended term. He says a criminal court has turned itself into a regulatory body.

The prosecution relies on section 99(3) of the Criminal Justice Act 2006, which it says enables the condition.

The Supreme Court said the application concerns the law applied to the sentence, not the facts. It noted the careful judgment of the Court of Appeal.

The court said more work is needed on sentencing bands in harassment and unlawful debt collection cases. It also found a matter of general public importance in how far a condition of suspension can continue beyond the suspended portion of a sentence.

The court set out three issues for the appeal. They are the sentencing bands in such cases, whether section 99(3) lets a court impose conditions beyond the 12 months suspended, with the possible imposition extending to 84 months, and what power a sentencing court has to regulate a convicted person's conduct.

The issues may be refined at case management.

The determination was made by O'Donnell J, MacMenamin J and Charleton J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal