Anthony McGrath, of Dublin 15, has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in a drink driving prosecution. The determination was delivered on 15 September 2020. The case was brought by the Director of Public Prosecutions at the suit of Garda Conor Gurn.
The point is narrow. In drink driving cases, the breath test result is proved by a statement under section 13 of the Road Traffic Act 2010. Here the original was not available, but a photocopy was put in evidence. The District Court asked the High Court, in a case stated, whether the legal presumption that such a statement is valid under section 20(1) of the Act applies to a photocopy.
Mr Justice Simons in the High Court said yes. The Court of Appeal agreed and dismissed Mr McGrath's appeal on 16 April 2020.
It was his second application to the Supreme Court. It had refused an earlier one, made directly from the High Court, in a determination of 11 October 2019.
In its earlier determination, the Supreme Court called the case "a matter of straightforward statutory interpretation". In this one it said a point is not of general public importance merely because it might affect drink driving prosecutions. The questions of fact, including whether there was an original and whether a photocopy was produced, were for the District Court.
It found no genuine controversy and no need for another appeal. The judges were Mr Justice O'Donnell, Ms Justice Dunne and Mr Justice Charleton.