Kevin Braney has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court. His case challenges a law on extending detention after arrest. The determination was delivered on 30 July 2020.
Mr Braney challenged section 30(3) of the Offences Against the State Act 1939. The High Court dismissed his challenge on 23 April 2020. He asked to appeal straight to the Supreme Court, skipping the Court of Appeal.
The section allows detention to be extended on the authorisation of a Garda officer of at least Chief Superintendent rank. Mr Braney says that is not enough. He relies on the Supreme Court decision in Damache v DPP. He also says a person arrested under section 30 is treated differently from one arrested under the Criminal Justice Act 1984. He says that is an unconstitutional interference with his rights.
He also says the section is incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights.
The respondents are the Special Criminal Court, Ireland and the Attorney General. They did not oppose leave and left it to the court. The Director of Public Prosecutions, the notice party, said she wishes to take part in the appeal.
The Supreme Court said a direct appeal is not justified merely because a case raises a point of law. The normal route is the Court of Appeal. A direct appeal needs extra reasons, such as urgency or wide-ranging effects.
It called this case perhaps marginal. The High Court had felt bound by an earlier decision, DPP v Quilligan and O'Reilly, which upheld section 30. Mr Braney disputes that. His appeal also raises how far courts may depart from precedent when a law has been upheld before.
The court said the provision is of some general importance. It also said the earlier decision could limit the Court of Appeal in ways that do not apply to the Supreme Court. It noted that the respondents did not resist leave.
The judges were Mr Justice O'Donnell, Mr Justice Charleton and Ms Justice O'Malley.