localnews.ie

Quinn Insurance granted Supreme Court appeal over PwC security for costs order

By Niamh Kearney

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will hear Quinn's appeal on 19 November 2020, after a Court of Appeal ruling that it must provide security for PwC's costs in its multimillion-euro claim.

Quinn Insurance Limited (under administration) has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in its long-running claim against the accountancy firm PricewaterhouseCoopers. The determination was delivered on 28 July 2020. PwC argued that no issue of general public importance arose.

Quinn is suing PwC for damages for alleged breach of contract, negligence and breach of duty. The claim concerns how PwC carried out its audits of certain aspects of Quinn's business and met certain regulatory requirements. The proceedings began in 2012 and were admitted to the Commercial Court on 24 July 2013.

Quinn was placed under administration by the High Court on 30 March 2010. It is now insolvent and non-trading, and relies on funding from the Insurance Compensation Fund. Its only remaining purpose is to pursue this claim.

The appeal concerns a motion by PwC for security for its costs. Mr Justice Haughton in the High Court refused it. On 21 April 2020 the Court of Appeal reversed that decision. It noted that the agreed estimate of likely costs was €30 million, and said it would be intrinsically unfair to expect PwC to carry the ultimate risk of costs of that size. It held that ordering security would not create an injustice to Quinn. The High Court is to decide the amount and mode of security.

Quinn says the Court of Appeal introduced a novel approach, treating the fact that security would not stifle the claim as a factor that could tip the balance. PwC says the court applied well-settled principles and exercised a discretion.

The Supreme Court said the application has considerable significance. It found issues of general public importance in identifying the appropriate test for security for costs and the public interest principle in section 52 of the Companies Act 2014. It also found that the interests of justice favour an appeal.

Quinn had sought a priority hearing because the Court of Appeal stayed the proceedings. The Supreme Court said it can now fix the hearing for 19 November 2020, with case management in September 2020.

The judges were Chief Justice Clarke, Mr Justice O'Donnell and Mr Justice MacMenamin.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal