Pat O'Leary has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his case against Volkswagen Group (Ireland) Limited. The determination was delivered on 21 July 2020. The company opposed the application.
Mr O'Leary is a car dealer. He held three Volkswagen distribution contracts for an indefinite period, signed on 24 September 2003. On 18 April 2011 he was served with notice terminating all three. Volkswagen said it had to reorganise its dealer network because of the downturn in the Irish economy. The contracts ended on 30 April 2013.
Mr O'Leary sued, saying the termination lacked the objective and transparent reasons required by the contract and by Article 3(4) of an EU block exemption regulation. In the High Court, Mr Justice Binchy agreed and awarded €10 in nominal damages and €100,000 in special damages.
The Court of Appeal reversed that decision on 3 February 2020, in a judgment by Ms Justice Costello. It found the reason given in the notice was objective and transparent.
The Supreme Court said there was no confusion about Article 3(4) and no doubt about how it applies. It said the case turned on a highly fact-specific set of circumstances. It also declined to refer questions to the Court of Justice of the EU, because none raised a new point of EU law.
The judges were Mr Justice McKechnie, Mr Justice Charleton and Ms Justice O'Malley.