David Kavanagh was refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court on 1 July 2020 over his bid to suspend emergency health legislation. He had taken the case against the Caretaker Government of Ireland and the President.
Mr Kavanagh asked the High Court to suspend the Health (Preservation and Protection and Other Emergency Measures in the Public Interest) Act 2020. He also wanted measures made under it suspended. He applied for an interim injunction without putting the State on notice. Mr Justice Allen refused the application on 8 April 2020.
Mr Kavanagh argued that the government was only a caretaker with limited functions. The Supreme Court said there was a very strong argument that a government continuing in office has the same powers as any other.
The court said a judge could suspend legislation without hearing the government only in the most extraordinary circumstances. Mr Kavanagh could have asked for a short-notice motion, which would have let the government be heard within days. He chose not to, and the court said that had consequences.
The court gave no view on whether the Act could be challenged. It said any such issues would only become clear after a full High Court hearing, and Mr Kavanagh can continue his case there.
The judges were Chief Justice Clarke, Ms Justice Dunne and Ms Justice Baker.