localnews.ie

Spamat S.R.L. refused Supreme Court appeal over ship Almirante Storni claim

By Niamh Kearney

Historic decision · Decision date:

The company cannot pursue the vessel for unpaid port services at Bari after the Supreme Court refused it leave to appeal.

Spamat S.R.L. has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in its claim over unpaid port services for the ship Almirante Storni. The determination was delivered on 29 June 2020. The owners of the vessel opposed the application.

The company claimed €38,314.07 for disbursements for the operation or maintenance of the ship at the port of Bari, Italy, between 4 March 2018 and 13 March 2018. GK Shipping, a Greek company with the vessel on a time charter, contracted the services.

The High Court dismissed the claim on 24 May 2019. Mr Justice McDonald found that GK Shipping ordered the services, that Spamat knew the legal difference between it and the owners, and that the owners were not shown to be personally liable. Without that liability, there was no right to pursue the vessel.

The Court of Appeal upheld that decision on 9 March 2020 in a judgment by Mr Justice McGovern. It found no evidence that the owners ratified the contract or that GK Shipping was their agent.

The Supreme Court said the questions Spamat raised could arise in a suitable case. But it said the facts found by the High Court, which the Court of Appeal held were supported by the evidence, meant they could not be considered here. They included that Spamat sought payment from GK Shipping before leaving port.

It saw no issue of general public importance and no interests-of-justice ground. The judges were Chief Justice Clarke, Ms Justice Dunne and Ms Justice Baker.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal