Patrick J Kelly has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his challenge to his dismissal as harbourmaster at Killybegs Fishery Harbour Centre in County Donegal. The determination was delivered on 15 June 2020. The respondents are the Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, the Minister for Finance, the Government of Ireland, Ireland and the Attorney General.
The Government confirmed Mr Kelly's dismissal after an investigation and an appeal hearing under the Civil Service Disciplinary Code 1/92. The investigator recommended dismissal, and the recommendation was upheld on appeal. The essential ground was Mr Kelly's admitted conduct in carrying out commercial piloted services in the harbour while he was harbourmaster.
Mr Kelly challenged that decision in the High Court, where Mr Justice Hedigan dismissed his case. The Court of Appeal upheld that decision in a judgment delivered on 17 December 2019 by Ms Justice Costello, with Mr Justice McGovern and Ms Justice Baker agreeing.
Mr Kelly argues the investigation was flawed. He says a Minister, who was also a local TD, contacted the Secretary of the Department of Agriculture and then met the investigating officer to raise concerns forcefully about his conduct as harbourmaster. It is accepted that neither the concerns nor the meeting were passed on to Mr Kelly during the investigation. No formal record was kept, but the investigating officer kept personal notes.
He contends this amounted to objective bias that the later review by the Appeal Board could not cure. He also points out that the Minister was at the Cabinet meeting that approved the dismissal recommendation, and says that vitiates the decision.
The Supreme Court said the appeal raises issues of law of general public importance. It granted leave on whether the meeting between the Minister and the investigating officer, or the Minister's participation in the Cabinet meeting, made the decision invalid. The grounds may be refined at case management.
The judges were Mr Justice O'Donnell, Mr Justice Charleton and Ms Justice Irvine.