localnews.ie

Geraldine Cantrell granted Supreme Court appeal in AIB Belfry property funds case

By Tadhg O'Sullivan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will hear a limitation issue in pathfinder claims by investors who put between €100,000 and €400,000 into the funds.

Geraldine Cantrell and other investors have been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in their claims over the Belfry Property Funds. The determination was delivered on 12 June 2020. Allied Irish Banks plc, the fund directors and the accountancy firm BDO are among the defendants.

The plaintiffs are bringing pathfinder claims. Those cases stand in for a total of 300 claims by individuals who invested in the funds, which operated under the auspices of AIB. They put in sums ranging from €100,000 to €400,000 between 2002 and 2006.

The funds aimed to buy commercial property in secondary locations in the UK, with 80 percent of the price to be funded by borrowing. The loans carried loan-to-value covenants. If property values fell, the lenders could declare a default and sell the properties, and the investment would be lost. The investors say they did not know the loan terms until the events behind the case.

Values rose at first. By August 2008 the investors were told values had dropped back to near parity. In 2009 they were told the portfolio had fallen by 31 percent. The properties began to be sold in 2013 and the investors lost all of their investment.

The proceedings began in 2014. The key question is when the cause of action arose, which decides whether the claims are statute-barred. If the damage happened when the loans were negotiated, the claims are out of time. If it happened when investors were alerted in August 2008 or later, they are in time. The High Court (Mr Justice Haughton) found they were in time. The Court of Appeal, in a judgment by Ms Justice Baker, reversed that on 18 July 2019.

The Supreme Court said the case raises a substantial issue of general public importance on when a cause of action in tort accrues and how the Statute of Limitations operates. It also found an appeal was in the interests of justice. Many investors are elderly, the money was retirement savings, and the limitation ruling could end the case or a large part of it.

Leave was granted on condition that the plaintiffs redraft their notice of appeal, which the court called lengthy and diffuse. The court declined to order a priority hearing, expecting a prompt hearing in the normal course, but the parties may apply again.

The judges were Mr Justice O'Donnell, Mr Justice Charleton and Ms Justice Irvine.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal