Clement Limen has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against his convictions for rape and sexual assaults. The determination was delivered on 5 June 2020. The Director of Public Prosecutions opposed the application.
Mr Limen was convicted on 31 May 2017 over events at a private residence on 2 June 2014. Two women made complaints against him. At trial he admitted intercourse with one of them and said it was consensual. The jury rejected his account.
He was refused leave to appeal his conviction by the Court of Appeal on 19 December 2019. His complaint centres on the prosecution's closing speech. He says counsel should not have suggested that the similarity between the two women's accounts supported their evidence. He argues the trial judge should then have explained when one complaint can support another.
The Court of Appeal found that defence counsel made an informed decision at trial to say nothing further, and that no fundamental injustice had occurred.
The prosecution said the case raised no issue of general public importance. It argued that all that happened was a normal address by counsel in a trial with two alleged victims.
The Supreme Court said it is not a court for the correction of error. But it said sexual violence cases with more than one alleged victim are likely to arise again. It said it matters to set out the law precisely where joint trials occur.
In the court's words: "Is support all that is required in these circumstances and should corroboration be mentioned at all?"
Leave was granted on three questions. Can the account of one alleged victim support the evidence of another? Does that apply only where the accounts are similar enough for the similar fact principle, or is it enough that they broadly agree? And what direction should a trial judge give a jury?
The judges were Mr Justice O'Donnell, Mr Justice Charleton and Ms Justice Irvine.