localnews.ie

Word Perfect Translation Services granted Supreme Court appeal in State tender dispute

By Tadhg O'Sullivan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will hear the company's appeal over discovery of documents in its challenge to an interpretation services contract awarded by the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform.

Word Perfect Translation Services Limited has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in its challenge to a State contract for interpretation services. The determination was delivered on 18 May 2020. The company is the applicant and the respondent is the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform.

The company is challenging the award of the contract by judicial review. The contract was awarded after a supplementary request for tenders issued by the Minister in February 2018. Word Perfect was told in October 2018 that it had lost. It scored 848.37 marks, and the successful tender scored 949.15. The company says there was a manifest error in the award.

The appeal arises from a dispute over discovery, the process by which one side obtains documents from the other. In the High Court, Mr Justice Simons granted all the discovery the company sought, covering nine headings of documents. The Court of Appeal reversed that decision entirely on 24 October 2019. Mr Justice Peart gave the decision, with Ms Justice Whelan and Mr Justice McGovern agreeing.

Word Perfect argued the case raised issues of general public importance. It also said an appeal was in the interests of justice. It said the contract has been awarded and performed, that there was no standstill period, and that the chance of any benefit from a declaration of ineffectiveness has passed. It claimed this breached its right to an effective remedy under EU law. The Minister said the Court of Appeal had simply applied settled case law, in particular a 2015 Court of Appeal decision in BAM v NTMA and Minister for Education, which the company had not challenged.

The Supreme Court said it is normally slow to accept that appeals over interlocutory matters meet the test for leave. It said the marked difference between the High Court and the Court of Appeal, which applied the same case law, suggested uncertainty remains in this area.

It also pointed to two questions of some importance for public procurement cases generally. One is whether the courts should apply a test similar to one used in England and Wales. The other is whether discovery may be refused on headings where the winning tenderer scored the same as, or less than, the challenger. The court was satisfied the issues justified an appeal.

The judges were Mr Justice O'Donnell, Mr Justice Charleton and Ms Justice Irvine.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal