localnews.ie

Marius Bogdan Zarnescu warrant case: Minister for Justice granted Supreme Court appeal

By Ruairí Dolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will hear the Minister's appeal directly from the High Court, which refused to surrender Mr Zarnescu to Romania under a European Arrest Warrant.

The Supreme Court has granted the Minister for Justice and Equality leave to appeal directly from the High Court in a European Arrest Warrant case involving Marius Bogdan Zarnescu. The determination was delivered on 5 May 2020 by the Chief Justice, Mr Justice MacMenamin and Ms Justice Baker. Mr Zarnescu opposed the application.

The Minister wanted to challenge a High Court order of 22 January 2020. In it, Mr Justice Binchy refused to surrender Mr Zarnescu to Romania under a warrant dated 23 January 2018. The warrant was issued by a judge of the Court of Onesti in respect of offences said to have been committed in Romania.

Mr Zarnescu objected to being surrendered on the ground that he had not been properly served with notice of the date of his appeal hearing in Romania. He was not present or represented when that appeal was decided or when he was sentenced. The appeal had been adjourned from 12 September 2017 to 7 November 2017, and notice was sent to an address where his father lived. His father signed for the letter, but Mr Zarnescu denies receiving the notification.

The Minister relied on an exception in section 45 of the European Arrest Warrant Act 2003. It applies where it is unequivocally established that the person knew the date of the hearing and knew a decision could be given in his absence. Mr Justice Binchy found it was merely likely that Mr Zarnescu had been notified, and that this fell short of unequivocal proof.

The Minister argued that cases about convictions imposed in absentia arise often and that the courts take different approaches to section 45. He pointed to a Court of Appeal decision in Minister for Justice and Equality v Skwierczynski, which rejected a literal reading of the section. He also raised whether Irish law meets the State's obligations under EU law.

The Supreme Court agreed that the correct approach to proof of service in the requesting state is a point of general public importance. It noted that the trial judge had observed that the domestic legislation may not adequately reflect EU law requirements, and that there may be a discordance with European case law. The court said the interests of justice required that leave be granted.

It added that the primary facts are established. A further question that may arise is whether an appeal court can review a conclusion drawn from primary facts found by a trial judge, and to what extent.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal