localnews.ie

Slawomir Palonka granted Supreme Court appeal against surrender to Poland

By Tadhg O'Sullivan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will consider whether a second European arrest warrant, issued years after the first was refused, amounts to an abuse of process.

Slawomir Viktor Palonka has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against an order directing his surrender to Poland. The Court delivered its determination on 24 March 2020. The Minister for Justice and Equality is the other party.

The High Court ordered his surrender on foot of a European arrest warrant issued on 29 January 2019. It relates to an offence from July 1999, when he is alleged to have persuaded his brother to import cannabis into Poland. On 23 August 2002 the Regional Court in Hrubieszow sentenced him to 10 months, conditionally stayed for three years. It activated that sentence on 16 January 2006, after what the warrant calls another offence during the stay.

This is the second warrant issued for Mr Palonka. The first, issued on 6 November 2012, concerned transporting marijuana from the Netherlands into Poland. Surrender was refused on that warrant by the Court of Appeal, because the Polish authorities did not provide the necessary information about a hearing held in his absence.

Mr Palonka argued that the new request is an abuse of process, given the delay and the fact that this offence was left out of the earlier proceedings. Mr Justice Binchy rejected his arguments in the High Court on 22 November 2019 and found no breach of his rights. Leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal was refused.

The Supreme Court said the case raises points of law of general public importance and that a further appeal is in the interests of justice. Leave is granted on two questions.

The first is whether issuing the second warrant, seven years after the first was issued and four years after surrender was refused, may be an abuse of process. The second is whether surrender may be ordered for the activation of a suspended sentence, in his absence, where that was triggered by a conviction in his absence for which surrender was refused.

The Court said it would decide in case management whether to ask the Polish authorities for more information. The panel was Justice McKechnie, Justice Charleton and Justice O'Malley.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal