localnews.ie

John Joseph Malone refused Supreme Court appeal over 1987 murder conviction

By Eimear Byrne

Historic decision · Decision date:

He was convicted at the Central Criminal Court of murdering Ann Nancy Smyth, and had argued that decades of delay prejudiced his defence.

The Supreme Court has refused John Joseph Malone leave to appeal against his murder conviction. The determination was delivered on 4 March 2020.

Mr Malone was convicted in the Central Criminal Court on 13 April 2017 of murdering Ann Nancy Smyth on 11 September 1987. The Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal on 19 April 2018. He applied to the Supreme Court on 3 January 2019.

Mr Malone said the long delay in prosecution had prejudiced him. He said other witnesses had died and the memories of living witnesses had faded. The Court of Appeal decided that his trial was fair and that his ability to defend himself was not unduly hampered.

The Director of Public Prosecutions said the evidence was cogent and the conviction secure. It pointed to admissions he was said to have made to others.

The Supreme Court was not convinced that a point of law of general public importance arose. It said the points raised on delay, confessions and old cases had recently been analysed in another judgment of the Court.

It also found nothing to show that the interests of justice required another appeal. The Court of Appeal's decision stands.

The panel was Justice O'Donnell, Justice Charleton and Justice O'Malley.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal