localnews.ie

Paddy McKeown and Adelaide McCarthy refused Supreme Court appeal in AIB debt case

By Niamh Kearney

Historic decision · Decision date:

They argued that the bank's summary procedure was unfair and that their loan came with an implied right to a reasonable opportunity to refinance.

The Supreme Court has refused Paddy McKeown and Adelaide McCarthy leave to appeal in Allied Irish Banks' case against them, in a determination delivered on 3 March 2020. The Court of Appeal decision of 28 November 2019 therefore stands.

The bank pursued the case by summary procedure. The applicants argued that this is unfair, because defendants have little time to establish facts while a bank may have spent months preparing. They also raised res judicata and the rule that an appeal court will not usually hear arguments not made at trial.

They further argued that the courts had misread the bank's letter of May 2013. The loan was repayable on demand, subject to repayment or refinancing on 31 December 2013. They said that meant an implied term giving them a reasonable opportunity to refinance. Both lower courts rejected that.

The applicants had lawyers in the High Court but represented themselves on appeal.

The Supreme Court said summary procedure is appropriate for debt cases and can be operated fairly. It said the contract point was one of interpretation, to which standard principles apply.

It found no issue of general public importance.

Leave to appeal is refused.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal