localnews.ie

Aer Arann refused Supreme Court leapfrog appeal over State aid air travel tax claims

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The High Court ordered the company to repay State aid; the Supreme Court said the Court of Appeal should hear any appeal first.

The Supreme Court has refused Comhfhorbairt (Gaillimh), trading as Aer Arann, leave to appeal directly from the High Court, in a determination delivered on 19 February 2020. The claims were brought by the Minister for Finance and Ireland.

The High Court ordered the company to pay €2,897,608 plus interest in one claim and €1,093,640 plus interest in the other. Both were decided in a single judgment by Mr Justice Barrett on 2 July 2019.

The claims rested on a European Commission decision of July 2012. It found that an air travel tax introduced in Ireland in March 2009 amounted to State aid to Irish airlines, and directed the State to recover it. The Court of Justice of the European Union upheld that decision on 21 December 2016.

Aer Arann said the claims were barred because it had gone through examinership in 2010. The High Court held that the Minister was not a contingent creditor and that res judicata could not block recovery of State aid.

The Supreme Court said an appeal to the Court of Appeal should be the norm. It was not shown that route was inadequate, and the Court of Appeal can refer European law questions to the Court of Justice.

Either side may seek leave from any Court of Appeal decision. The panel was Justice O'Donnell, Justice Charleton and Justice O'Malley.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal