John Gibbons has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his land sale dispute with Daniel Doherty and ADT Investments Limited. The decision was delivered on 18 February 2020.
Mr Gibbons is the plaintiff. The Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal on 30 October 2019. He applied for leave on 10 December 2019.
The contract was signed on 21 December 2006. It provided for the sale by Mr Gibbons of about 7.9ha of land in County Donegal. Mr Doherty signed it in trust. ADT Investments Limited did not exist at that date.
The sale was to take place in three tranches. The first was for €2m, the second for €1m and the third for €1m. The first two went ahead. The third did not, after the economic recession that followed 2008.
Mr Gibbons issued a plenary summons dated 21 May 2009. He sought specific performance and damages in lieu against Mr Doherty personally. In the High Court, Mr Justice Murphy ruled against him on 14 March 2013.
The Supreme Court said the case raises a point of law of importance to every solicitor in the State, and to developers and purchasers of property. The respondents argued that no matter of general public importance arises.
Leave is granted on four questions. The first two concern General Condition 30 of the Law Society conditions of sale. They ask whether it applies to a person or company not identified, or not yet in existence, when the contract is signed.
The third asks whether this was a single contract that has been part performed. The fourth asks whether the vendor's acceptance of the new company bars any relief.
The Court said the questions may be refined at case management. The panel was Justice O'Donnell, Justice Charleton and Justice O'Malley.